Thursday, October 02, 2014

Your Argument Is Invalid


http://cdn.staticportent.com/images/2013/05/zero-sum.png
Image
I have been in many arguments and by my count I have won all of them. Everyone else involved in these arguments might give a slightly different view point, where I do not have quite as good record. As I got a little older, I was able to reflect on these arguments I lost in my late teens and early twenties, and found something very interesting. Being right does not mean that you will win. This was something that I just did not understand. How could I be right, even being able to prove it, and still lose? I was not until years later that I figured out that the situation were using solely logic to win is as rare as hens teeth. Most people will not be persuaded by logic alone, it can make them angry and unreasonable. I if logic worked, I do not think that much of the strife we find in the world today would exist. It is at this point that Chapter 13 comes in and saves us with one world “persuasion.” This was the what I was missing when I was younger. Well that and a valid argument, but that is beside the point. Persuasion is an essential part of any argument you need to wrap the argument in persuasion to make it palatable. Something that I think that the comic “Argument Beyond Pro and Con,” that we were given as additional reading, demonstrates well. With only zero-sum arguments the chance of winning is greatly reduced, because someone else has to lose. Which is not something that anyone will willing do. Instead, creating the “argument/persuasion sandwich” as shown in the comic. You blend the all the tools need for a winning position. Which if done well, can be quite light on the logic part and do better than an argument full of absolute proof. Tools which I could have used with in was younger. 

- Austin

Reading Response Ch. 13 & Argument Beyond Pro and Con


Reading Response: Chapter 13 and Argument Beyond Pro and Con

Ch. 13 emphasizes on Persuasion vs. Argumentation.  Whether it is encouraging a person to feel the same way as another or to coerce a person into understanding a viable statement, it is important to have the appropriate backup.  After reading the chapter, I was able to understand the difference between both and how one can relate to another.

Persuasion is a way to guide a person into doing or believing something.  It is based on emotions and personal ideas or feelings about something.    It can be used when arguing a point, along with presenting appropriate evidence, to allure the reader into believing and following the statement.

Argumentation is used to convince readers in a logical and effective analysis to agree with the main idea.  It is backed up by evidence and supported with proper information.  Both argumentative and persuasive writing are used to persuade.

In the comic Argument Beyond Pro and Con we see examples of both, argument and persuasion.  It was a great way to represent the authors idea behind argumentative writing. The comics represented several real life situations, couples arguing, friends convincing friends.  Being able to see the visuals helped paint a clean picture of why it is important to back up information with proper research and evidence, as many of the comics displayed.

Providing personal experiences and observations can help the reader identify with the author, and perhaps offer a better point of view.  At times the truth may not always be convincing to a person, yet being able to relate and create a relationship might captivate a reader through his emotions and morals.

At times, I feel I have been caught under somebody else's persuasion regardless of facts.  Other times, the information I got was of most importance when making a decision.  When an author is trying to connect with a reader I think that both are as much influence when making any decision.
Image: N.d. Http://www.spring.org.uk/2010/11/balanced-arguments-are-more-persuasive.php. Web.